Cassandra Peterson better known as Elvira; Mistress of the Dark collaborated with Mattel to create a limited-edition Monster High Elvira.

The Elvira Monster High doll, which was announced on social media on Jan. 8, wrought waves of disappointed fans after pre-orders went live on Jan. 13 on Mattel Creations. Within minutes, the doll, which sold domestically for $65 plus shipping and tax, was listed as “sold out.”